NGSSoftware Insight Security Research Advisory
Name: Unauthenticated Remote Compromise in MS SQL Server 2000
Systems: Microsoft SQL Server 2000, all Service Packs
Severity: Critical/Very High Risk.
Category: Remote Buffer Overrun Vulnerability
Vendor URL: http://www.microsoft.com/
Author: David Litchfield (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Advisory URL: http://www.ngssoftware.com/advisories/mssql-udp.txt
Date: 25th July 2002
Advisory number: #NISR25072002
VNA reference : http://www.ngssoftware.com/vna/ms-sql.txt
This advisory covers the solution to one of the problems mentioned in the above VNA URL.
Microsoft's database server SQL Server 2000 exhibits two buffer overrun vulnerabilities that can be exploited by a remote attacker without ever having to authenticate to the server. What further exacerbates these issues is that the attack is channeled over UDP. Whether the SQL Server process runs in the security context of a domain user or the local SYSTEM account, successful exploitation of these security holes will mean a total compromise of the target server and its data.
SQL Server can be configured to listen for incoming client connections in several different ways. It can be configured such that clients can use named pipes over a NetBIOS session (TCP port 139/445) or sockets with clients connecting to TCP port 1433 or both. Which ever method is used the SQL Server will always listen on UDP port 1434. This port is designated as the Microsoft SQL Monitor port and clients will send a message to this port to dynamically discover how the client should connect to the Server. This message is a single byte packet, the byte being 0x02.
There are other messages that can be sent to this port and these can be worked out with simple experimentation.
Stack Based Buffer Overflow
When SQL Server receives a packet on UDP port 1434 with the first byte set to 0x04, the SQL Monitor thread takes the remaining data in the packet and attempts to open a registry key using this user supplied information. For example, by sending \x04\x41\x41\x41\x41 (0x04 followed by 4 upper case 'A's) SQL Server attempts to open
HKLM\Software\Microsoft\Microsoft SQL Server\AAAA\MSSQLServer\CurrentVersion
By appending a large number of bytes to the end of this packet, whilst preparing the string for the registry key to open, a stack based buffer is overflowed and the saved return address is overwritten. This allows an attacker to gain complete control of the SQL Server process and its path of execution. By overwriting the saved return address on the stack with an address that contains a "jmp esp" or "call esp" instruction, when the vulnerable procedure returns the processor will start executing code of the attacker's choice. At no stage does the attacker need to authenticate.
Heap Based Buffer Overflow
When SQL Server receives a packet on UDP port 1434 with the first byte set to 0x08 followed by an overly long string, followed by a colon character (:) and number a heap based buffer is overflowed. As this corrupts the structures used to keep track of the heap an attacker can overwrite any location in memory with 4 bytes of their own choosing. This can be used to gain remote control of the processes execution. If the colon and number are missing the SQL Server process access violates before the heap is corrupted as the code in the SQL Monitor thread fails to handle exceptions.
For example the code calls the C function strtok(). The strtok() functions looks for a given token in a string, in this case a colon, and if found returns a pointer to it. If the colon is missing in the string being searched then no pointer is returned. This is one of the reasons why the SQL Server process access violates if the colon is missing. The code does not check to see if a valid pointer has been returned before passing it to another function call, atoi():
ptr = strtok(string,":");
num = atoi(ptr); // ptr is used without being validated
Failure to check return values and handle exceptions leads to the process dying, leading to a simple Denial of Service attack. That said, in the light of the overflows, the DoS is the least of the problems.
Network Based Denial of Service
When an SQL Server receives a single byte packet, 0x0A, on UDP port 1434 it will reply to the sender with 0x0A. A problem arises as SQL Server will respond, sending a 'ping' response to the source IP address and source port. This 'ping' is a single byte UDP packet - 0x0A. By spoofing a packet from one SQL Server, setting the UDP port to 1434, and sending it the a second SQL Server, the second will respond to the first's UDP port 1434. The first will then reply to the second's UDP port 1434 and so on. This causes a storm of single byte pings between the two servers. Only when one of the servers is disconnected from the network or its SQL service is stopped will the storm stop. This is a simple newtork based DoS, reminiscent of the echo and chargen DoSes discussed back in 1996 (http://www.cert.org/advisories/CA-1996-01.html). When in this state, the load on each SQL Server is raised to c. 40 - 60 % CPU time.
Considerations for protection against these vulnerabilities
Exploitation of these security holes goes over UDP, a connection-less communications protocol. As such it makes the task of bypassing the protection offered by a firewall considerably easier. The spoofing of an IP address in a UDP packet is also considerably easier.
It is trivial for an attacker to send an attack through the firewall, setting the source IP address to that of the target's DNS Server and the source port to 53. Most firewalls will allow this packet through as it will look like a response to a query to resolve a domain name.
It is strongly recommended that a rule be added to each organization's firewall such that any packet destined for UDP port 1434 on the 'clean' side of the firewall be dropped and logged. No host, even DNS Servers, should be allowed to send traffic to this port.
It is also recommend that firewall administrators ensure that any packet received on the 'dirty' interface with a source IP address set to an address on the clean side is also dropped and logged.
NGSSoftware alerted Microsoft to this problem on the 17th of May 2002 and they have produced a patch that resolves these issues. NGSSoftware urge all customers of SQL Server 2000 to test then apply these fixes as soon as possible.
Where possible, NGSSoftware also recommend running the SQL Server as low privileged local account and not SYSTEM or a domain account.
A check for these vulnerabilities has been added to Typhon II, NGSSoftware'svulnerability assessment scanner, of which, more information is available from the NGSSite, http://www.ngssoftware.com/
The author will be discussing these vulnerabilities in detail, with several exploitation demonstrations, at the up and coming Blackhat Security Briefings conference is Las Vegas. For those interested in attending this conference, please see http://www.blackhat.com for more details.
For more information about buffer overflows please read