The latest instance of this discrepancy between opinions hit the news when a copy of a letter sent by the American Civil Liberties Union to Maryland’s Public Safety and Correctional Services Secretary Gary Maynard was made public.
The letter was sent by the Union on behalf of one Robert Collins, a Corrections Officer that was asked to hand over the login credentials of his social media accounts when he was undergoing recertification, and concerns this instance in particular and this specific Division of Correction's blanket requirement in general.
For those who might not know, everyone who is applying for a job with the Division of Correction and those who already work for it but are undergoing certification are required to fork over said login credentials, and the ACLU argues that "the DOC policy constitutes a frightening and illegal invasion of privacy for DOC applicants and employees -- as well those who communicate with them electronically via social media."
"Login information gives the DOC access to communications that are intended to be private, such as personal e-mail messages and wall postings viewable only by those selected individuals who have been granted access," states the letter. "For social media users who maintain private accounts, the DOC demand for login information is equivalent to demands that they produce all of their private correspondence and photographs for review, or permit the government to listen in on their personal telephone calls, as a condition of employment."
The ACLU maintains that the DOC policy is illegal under the federal Stored Communications Act and are a major instance of invasion of privacy, and they ask for its immediate repeal. The letter was sent almost a month ago, and they have still to hear from Secretary Maynard.
And while the majority of people are likely to sympathize with the request and find the DOC's requirement appalling, it may be a good idea to consider these accounts public from the get-go and to think long and hard about posting potentially sensitive information. The law may or may not occasionally be on your side, but you yourself should always be.