Defending against the BREACH attack
by Ivan Ristic - Thursday, 8 August 2013.
HTTP chunked encoding mitigation

The award for least-intrusive and entirely painless mitigation proposal goes to Paul Querna who, on the httpd-dev mailing list, proposed to use the HTTP chunked encoding to randomize response length. Chunked encoding is a HTTP feature that is typically used when the size of the response body is not known in advance; only the size of the next chunk is known. Because chunks carry some additional information, they affect the size of the response, but not the content. By forcing more chunks than necessary, for example, you can increase the length of the response. To the attacker, who can see only the size of the response body, but not anything else, the chunks are invisible. (Assuming they're not sent in individual TCP packets or TLS records, of course.)

This mitigation technique is very easy to implement at the web server level, which makes it the least expensive option. There is only a question about its effectiveness. No one has done the maths yet, but most seem to agree that response length randomization slows down the attacker, but does not prevent the attack entirely. But, if the attack can be slowed down significantly, perhaps it will be as good as prevented.

Referer check mitigation

A quick, dirty, tricky, and a potentially unreliable mitigation approach you can apply today, is to perform Referer header checks on all incoming requests. Because the attacker cannot inject requests from the web site itself (unless he gains access via XSS, in which case he owns the browser and has no need for further attacks), he must do so from some other web site (a malicious web site, or an innocent site hijacked from a MITM location). In that case, the referrer information will show the request originating from that other web site, and we can easily detect that.

Now, you can't just drop such requests (because then no links to your web site would work any more), but you can drop all the cookies before they reach the application. Without the cookies, your application will not resume the victim's session, and won't place anything secret in the response. Attack mitigated.

There is a catch, however (as @hubert3 pointed out to me): if your web site relies on being framed by arbitrary 3rd party web sites, or if it exposes public services to others (for browser consumption), then you can't use this defence. I am assuming your services need the cookies. If they do not, you're back in the game. If you do decide to try it, please test your major use cases in a staging environment first.

You can implement this defence with only two Apache directives:

SetEnvIfNoCase Referer ^($|https://www\.example\.com/) keep_cookies
RequestHeader unset Cookie env=!keep_cookies

The cookies are kept for requests arriving from the same site, as well as those arriving without referrer information (e.g., from a bookmark). There's a potential problem with users that follow links from other sites (not bookmarks) and expect to be logged in straight away. For such users you might need to have a welcome page, where you will ask them to click on a link to enter the web site. The cookies will be sent again on the next request.

Just to be clear, there is a long history of attacks focusing on spoofing the Referer header. For example, there was one such problem in Chrome just recently. However, such attacks are addressed quickly after discovery.

To conclude, I can't really say that I like this approach, but its huge advantage is that you can deploy it very quickly at the web server or reverse proxy level, without having to make any changes to the application code. Even with all the constraints, I imagine there will be a large number of applications for which the trade-offs will be acceptable.

Spotlight

Targeted attack protection via network topology alteration

Posted on 17 October 2014.  |  This article from Trend Micro tackles how network topology can aid in defending the enterprise network from risks posed by targeted attacks.


Weekly newsletter

Reading our newsletter every Monday will keep you up-to-date with security news.
  



Daily digest

Receive a daily digest of the latest security news.
  

DON'T
MISS

Mon, Oct 20th
    COPYRIGHT 1998-2014 BY HELP NET SECURITY.   // READ OUR PRIVACY POLICY // ABOUT US // ADVERTISE //